Wednesday, December 9, 2009
Sustainability 2.0
Tuesday, December 8, 2009
Sustainability 2.0
sustainability 2
Sustainability endgame
Re-evaluating Sustainability
Remember the Idea
In my first definition of sustainability, I said it was the ability to preserve the world, the environment and the life in it. I think this is what sustainability should be, but isn’t always interpreted as. Sustainability has come to replace previous vague words like environmental, green, and organic to name a few. The problem with all of these words is the people interpreting them, the people who are going to ignore the intended connotation of the word in an effort to be labeled “green” or “sustainable” or whatever the word may be because that implies to everyone else that you are better than the competition. What I mean is that greedy people look for loopholes. For example, some juice companies will advertise their juice as “organic from concentrate” or “organic flavoring” but what do those phrases even mean anymore? I can’t imagine that organic flavoring is any better than regular flavoring.
The word “organic” no longer has very much weight because it has been interpreted and reinterpreted to fit various money-making schemes. Similarly, “green” has lost its connotative meaning just as “sustainable” will likely lose its power. Sustainable literally just means the ability to sustain. The “what” must be added. To sustain life? To sustain the environment? Those ideas are intended to be implied but they might be lost as the market tries to manipulate “sustainable” products.
In general, the vast amount of things sustainability can be applied to (like the 12+ types of sustainability named by Curran) makes using the word “sustainability” both a vice and a virtue. It’s nice because it can be applied to any situation. It’s bad because it can be misinterpreted, misleading, or manipulated. I think “sustainable” is better left as an adjective as Newton and Frefogle suggested. The reason it is so vague is because it is intended as a modifier – it requires the “what” as I said before.
I hate criticizing something without offering a solution, but frankly I don’t know what kind of word would perfectly encompass all of these new ideas about the environment. Maybe that word doesn’t exist yet. Maybe we don’t have one word to recall every subject Curran brought up, but the most important point is to remember those ideas regardless. We must hold on to the meaning – focus not on the dictionary or technical definitions, but rather on the idea, the lifestyle, and the movement behind sustainability and whatever new words we may begin to use in the future. “A man may die, nations may rise and fall, but an idea lives on. Ideas have endurance without death.” (JFK)
What is sustainability?
"Sustainability and me"
Issues of “sustainability” pertain to everything around me – after all, there doesn’t seem much point to anything else if I cannot live and breathe in the world that I have helped create. As Derrick Jensen says, “If you have no planet, nobody can ask questions.” So how do we humans address such a broad, all-encompassing matter? Sustainability is not just an “environmental” issue – it concerns matters from animal welfare and economics to social justice and human rights. For developed, industrialized countries such as the United States, I do not think that sustainability is about prolonging our current standards of living for as long as possible - we are going to have to find a new way to live more equitably. However, what would that look like? Imagining that future can be rather bleak and scary – I know that I have grown rather accustomed to the many luxuries that my country provides. However, as illustrated by The Story of Stuff, such amenities come at a hefty price. The richer developed world may not be paying as dearly for our actions yet, but the environment and poorer developing countries are already bearing the brunt of such choices. I do not think we have the luxury to tiptoe around these issues - we can no longer afford for issues of sustainability to be divisive or ignored.
At times, the weight and breadth of these issues can be very intimidating and confusing. However, the longer the world waits, the more nebulous our future seems to get. Our little actions certainly add up - we have to start somewhere. But I think that "sustainability" demands more from us - it requires actions that reach farther than our individual lives. Our personal changes are certainly a step in the right direction, but I don’t think it can stop there. World-wide discussion of our species' role as responsible and compassionate stewards of the Earth *is* growing – a fact that heartens and motivates me. I want to believe that the world is starting to see how sustainability is an issue that concerns us all – an aspect that I hope can give it a strong, unifying power.
In conclusion, I liked the idea of sustainability being more of a verb than a noun. Not something to mostly just talk about, but something that we do. I think that the issues we face today are some of the greatest challenges ever to our creativity as a species – how can we look past the linear way so many things are done to fashion a new, cyclical, and “sustainable” way of living?
Sustainability?
Because it is so amorphous everyone has their own definition of sustainability, and so attempting to take into account all I’ve learned here is my best personal definition of sustainability. When I think of sustainability “reduce, reuse, recycle” still comes to mind immediately. But this is simply a way of life incorporating a mindset of sustainability. Sustainability is a much broader word, including not only a path and way of life, but also a goal. Even the goal of sustainability is somewhat amorphous. This goal is a continuous goal as one must continue the practices used to “achieve” this goal once it is reached. But I do feel like sustainability can be a goal, just one that continues to compound each time it is reached. As Zoë mentioned in her first blog, infinity is a fitting symbol when describing sustainability. Basically, to be truly sustainable, a process must be able continue infinitely. But then when describing sustainability in the world at this point, we cannot call anything truly sustainable. We would like to put all our hopes on technology, but even this has a cost. Thus, this definition of sustainability is a bit unrealistic and idealistic in practice. Yet, we do need something to aspire to and the cyclical feel of infinity is perfection. To me, the word sustainability will never include being one with the land. This is probably because I have been influenced by traditional views of sustainability and the way in which past and present governments define it. We can and should base models off of nature’s perfectly cyclical processes while trying to live more in harmony with the land, but as much as I wish sustainability could include that oneness with the land I do not feel like it does right now. That is one of the problems with the word sustainability, although to some people it does mean achieving a better state with the environment we are a part of, to most, sustainability is almost solely focused on humans and looks at the environment as a place of resources- renewable and nonrenewable. Due to this fact we may never reach the full meaning of the word sustainability because without that appreciation and connection to the Earth we will not be able to connect all the dots. Don’t get me wrong, I do believe there is hope for humanity and this beautiful Earth which we live on. But I also think it will take a lot for us to change, and I worry that if the bar is set too high people will feel as though it is unattainable and thus not worth attempting to achieve. Then we will never reach our goal of “sustainability” (however you define it).
Home
In Society, many people push for sustainability and attempt practices that are "more sustainable." In reality, these people are attempting to grasp an intangible object. Sustainability's role in society has become a view where it has almost become a finish line--once it is reached people can stop running the race. In contrast to the thought of many, it is actually a state of mind that will probably be brought on when humanity is knocking at death's door. This mentality would dicates one's behaviors to things such as recycling anything used back through natural process of the Earth, while not harming the planet in any way. If humans are to reach this state, keeping the average American's lifestyle today would be impossible with the amount of waste and consumpton that goes on. One would probably even have to go to the extent of submerging them self completely into nature and "living off the land," but wouldn't it be kind of cool if everyone did that? I know I don't want to pay taxes and work all day!
If the Lifestyle Project and other student's activism projects showed me one thing about being sustainable other than it being a lifestyle, it is that in order to be more sustainable, one must also develop a more intimate relationship with your surroundings. This means going outside for natural light instead of using electrical lights indoors, or spending time with the people in your building in place of spending time with your television. Sustainability will certainly not be impossible, but will not be easy either, and will require the commitment of everyone to accept change in the sake of something bigger than themselves. When humanity cannot continue any longer and everything we rely on is gone, we will need to either form together or we will fall apart.
"Only when the last tree has been cut, the last river is polluted, and the last fish has been caught will we realize we cannot eat money." -Native American Cree proverb
Sustainability is...
hard to define. It lacks a solid meaning beyond the idea that it is about meeting our needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Furthermore, the fact that it is “an adjective dressed up as a noun” (Newton and Freyfogle) reflects the misconception of what sustainability really means. Rather than sustainability being the goal that should be reached in the future, it is the ongoing method of how to reach that goal. However, the question of what is being sustained and who is doing the sustaining still remains unclear (Newton and Freyfogle).
Sustainability needs to continue and improve its development from a local all the way up to a global perspective requiring us to have a more efficient integration between our society, environment, and economy. As individuals, we need to become more aware of our consumption and waste, especially when “14% of our food is wasted,” (Pollan) and continue doing our part as our small actions do make a difference, although it’s a fact major changes will only be achieved through policy. Unfortunately, it is our industries and economy that are failing to undertake sustainable practices given that they have the largest impact on our own ability to become sustainable individuals. With a large percentage of our food products containing corn syrup from inedible corn (King Corn), the need for 600 gallons of water to create a single hamburger patty (Ryan), and the fact that the cost of an aluminum soda can costs more than the soda inside (Ryan) emphasize the need for these changes to occur.
Monday, December 7, 2009
sustainability v2.0
I've enjoyed taking this class with people who have different opinions about sustainability. It's refreshing, and I've learned quite a bit. See you all in Sustainability 201.
Here we go again
Sustainability 2.0
Sustainability: Take 2
Sustainability 2.0
Sustainability 2.0
Sustainability: Take 2
What is Sustainability? 2.0
Sustainability is a process. This is not something that has an ultimate outcome and then it is over. True sustainability is a way of life and an ongoing set of choices. The word sustainable inherently has the word sustain in it, this means that the environment must be able to sustain itself. The reason the environment is so important is because this is the place where everything, not just humans lives. So it is important to maintain the natural cycles that allow change, yet sustain the ecosystem.
A common misconception about sustainability is that it is something that can be achieved. A society can become more sustainable, but unless the actions are ongoing then it is not sustainable. Sustainability implies the use of long term plans, goals, and actions that provide equal opportunities for future generations, indefinitely. The vagueness of the word sustainability allows it to be modified to different cultures, ecosystems, and ideas.
The idea of sustainability includes other initiatives such as conservation, preservation, and restoration. The ideas of conservation and preservation are essential, to observe how nature deals with certain situations, so that humans can re-learn how to mimic nature. This is also necessary to prevent further habitats and species from being destroyed. Once this re-learning has taken place, or at least started to, then restoration can begin. Restoration is possible even more important in striving to be more sustainable as a species. This concept encompasses the idea of trying to remedy past mistakes of overuse, or simply damaging the environment. Biodiversity is essential for maintaing or sustaining the ecosystem’s natural ability to adjust to change. Preserving the integrity of certain things such as soil and water systems is essential, because without maintaining the basics of an environment, the ecosystem cannot replenish itself.
Sustainability is also a mindset, overcoming the idea of human exceptionalism. This idea implies that humans are better than other species and that humans are isolated from the environment. However, through the use of machinery humans have actually had an even greater impact on the environment that many other species. With the ability to travel great distances, such as oceans away, humans have also been responsible for introducing many non-native species, causing native populations to undergo immense pressure. This extra pressure is simply due to carelessness and arrogance.
Sustainability is a form of knowing. Especially a knowing of how the environment works and how to fit into the natural system, rather than trying to step outside of the environmental limits. Although these limits may seem detrimental to the human race, they are a way of keeping each species in check. With the industrial revolution, humans has been able to overcome many of these environmental limits. The only problem with this is that humans have overcome these boundaries with no regard to the consequences. Respect for the environment combined with knowledge of environmental impacts is crucial to sustainability because if you lack respect then there is no motivation to become sustainable. The earth is an amazing ecosystem that provides a tremendous amount of resources, which can be utilized by people. However, if the environment is not cared for then it will no longer be able to provide these resources for people and other living beings. This is what environmental sustainability is all about, maintain the environment in order to continue to be able to sustain life.
The New View (Sustainability 2.0)
I guess since I'm vegan, I've always focused on eating in a way that I feel like lessens my impact on the environment. Even the food production week exposed me to new information though, with the King Corn movie. Man, that movie opened my eyes to something I would have never expected-that our country is based off of one vegetable. Like I've said in previous blogs, two of my siblings are allergic to corn. My brother is mildly allergic to corn, and he just decided to disregard his allergy and eat anything he wants and suffer from occasional migraines. My sister though, has extensive allergies and corn is on her "red list" which contain things that cause her serious health issues. While my brother has known the source of his problems for a long time, my sister just found her's out. So whenever I went home for Thanksgiving, I decided to give my sister's diet a try. Let me tell you, people think being a vegan sounds difficult, try living without corn.
Anywho, I definitely expanded upon my understanding of the different aspects of sustainability. For example, I always had a vague understanding that transportation=bad, but I honestly never thought much into solutions other than new alternatives to fuel and things along those lines. I really enjoyed the Rosenthal article about the German suburb that just didn't have cars at all. Who would've thought that could happen in modern society. During my technology fast, and I guess even being vegan, I felt so liberated not depending on things that everyone else seems to rely so heavily upon. I hope in the future I won't have a car, I definitely think if I plan it out correctly, its a very reasonable possibility.
And just to follow up on the discussion over whether we like the word "sustainability", I thought about it more, and my opinion still stands. I like the word sustainability. I know a lot of people were against the word because its so vague. If it truely is an environmentalist's goal to make the world a healthier place to live, then they should embrace a word that allows for personal interpretations. If someone takes it very loosely, and decides that simply recycling is going to produce a more sustainable environment, so be it! I feel like every drop sort of counts in the end, so no matter how you decide to translate sustainability into the actions you make in your life, its better than doing nothing. I think the ambiguity is its strong point, because it allows for the majority of the population to join the "sustainability movement". And I think environmentalists should be happy with this, even if some people are in it for shallow reasons, they're participating. Even if people are just doing it to be trendy, at least they're doing it.
In a perfect world, passing on my good habits is by definition "sustainability.
Thursday, December 3, 2009
SU BIKE SHED, THE EPIC.
Tuesday, December 1, 2009
Getting Fresh
Saturday, November 28, 2009
End of the Project
What I am most happy about, however, is how the project has effected my health/life overall. Not only am I living with a little less impact on the health of the planet, but I have been eating more healthy as well. I find myself with the habit now of looking at labels for ingredients, weeding out the unhealthy from the healtheir choices, and hearing the arguement for boycotting meat in my head every time I reach for a burger. Although I am not a vegetarian, I can't help but feel like I have an understanding as to how vegetarians can choose the lifestyle they live, and even a tenacity to support them in their efforts. After all, why should we support industries with unhealthy practices that produce questionable products and pollute the environment?
A more abstract synopsis of the Lifestyle Project, however, may be Dr. Van Horn's infultration of our daily life to eventually recruit us for his environmentalist-army...
Tuesday, November 24, 2009
My New Life
more digging in the dirt
The last time that I was out at the garden, I was there longer than usual and it seemed like I got less done. Some weeds are more resilient than others I guess. But I know that in order to get the job done right, you have to spend time at it. If you don't try to get the entire plant out of the ground, you risk it growing back again. Hopefully, more work now will mean less later. I appreciate all of the others that have been helping. My project will be ongoing. I have been taking photos as the hillside has been cleaned up and I will continue until the project is finished. I live in the area and will hopefully have the opportunity to work on the hillside during the winter break. I look forward to seeing it completed and am excited to be working on a project that will benefit those on campus for a long time. Everyone should stop by next spring and see the results. Happy Thanksgiving!!!
Overall, a Great Experience
These three changes have taught me quite a bit about how to live a bit simpler and more carefully. The easiest of my three challenges was still reducing my electricity and water. I have learned lots of little tricks to reduce water usage that will be in my life for the rest of my life. For example, I found that if I don’t get ice in my cup, all of the water a get at a meal will not be wasted. I’ve found how to reuse water; sometimes using the same water for lots of dishes, or using runoff to shave my legs. For electricity, I found I just hardly ever need lights on. In my attempt to save electricity, I found myself going outside more often to get work done, and I found that quite enjoyable. It has even made me be around people more often. To keep the lights off, I would go sit in my hall with other people at night. The food changes I’ve made will have an extremely lasting effect on me. I don’t know that for the rest of my life I will no longer be a glutton, in fact I know I will always have my gluttonous moments. However, from this point forward I know that I will always eat consciously. Each time I get up for another serving I will think first. I found this last week that even on days that I didn’t specify as no food waste days, I still would be hesitant to get a second serving. At the end of each day of only eating what I needed and not wasting any food, I was so proud. It will be nice to continue that feeling. The most fun experience of all this was the laundry day. That was a huge success. I will post pictures very soon. It was so much fun. I spent the whole day outside and found I loved drying peoples laundry for them, it was rewarding. The lines were right by the highway for all the cars on Southwestern Blvd to see. Every hour or so, there was a honk. I like to think they honked because it was a great idea (although that may be wishful thinking). You know what else I found? I thought the laundry lines were absolutely beautiful. They made me smile all day. After Sunday, I cannot imagine why neighborhood associations would ban drying laundry outside. I think they could bring something wonderful to a neighborhood. It’s a great idea; a solar powered dryer.
endings and beginings

During the final week of this sustainability project, the temperature decreased a bit, re-enforcing not planting many flowers at the end of November. However, I was able to transplant a few tropical sage flowers from my house (we have an abundance). Their red flowers liven up the shade. I also made a bird’s eye view of where to plant the flowers and I drew a picture of the flowers together. I hope to post these as soon as I figure out how.
I know I can get turkscaps at an organic nursery near Smithville, if I can’t find a local source. The other flowers I will try to find as the temperatures warm. This project is ongoing, and will hopefully eventually spread out of the garden to the dorm rooms and home with students.
This is the beginning of a continuous project, that I hope will continue to be maintained even after I graduate. I feel like having flowers in a shady area will liven it up and show people that there can be color and life everywhere. Perhaps this area will be expanded to also grow vegetables or herbs, but for now it is just native flowers to bring joy, right at the front of the garden.
Wrapping it up
It’s amazing how quickly these past few weeks have flown by! Of the three catagories that I selected for my lifestyle project, I’d have to say that garbage elimination was the hardest. A person truly doesn’t realize how much throw away in 1 day, until it is forbidden. I was not aware that most of what I eat is disposable. So many times I went to pop a bag of popcorn or toast a pop tart without realizing that, alas, I could not. Having completed this project, I am ashamed to say that I am going to continue throwing things away. However, now I will think twice before I dispose of something that could be reusable or check to see if it is recyclable. My second biggest challenge for this project was initiating some changes, ie recycling bins and the elimination of Styrofoam cups, in my workplace (Innerspace Cavern) . Recycling bins were badly needed next to all of the registers because of all the receipts and aluminum cans that get tossed out every day, and everyone knows that Styrofoam is just plain bad. I thought that, perhaps, there would be some extra bins in the warehouse that I could use for my project so that I would not have to go out and use up more resources, but unfortunately, there was not. I went out and bought 6 recycling bins: one for the gift shop, one for the ticket booth, two for the snack bar, and two for the office spaces behind closed doors. Then, I painted the bins green and labeled them “Paper Recycling” and one “Aluminum Recycling” so that everyone would know what they are. Every Sunday, when I work, I am going to take the recycling to a bin close by my house. I plan to continue this process as long as I work at Innerspace. It needs to be done, and no one else is going to do it. Unfortunately, I wasn’t able to get anything accomplished with the elimination of Styrofoam cups . The last phase of my project was water and electricity conservation. This was probably the least challenging because I already use very little electricity and water. However, I did notice that when I shower in the mornings and I am half awake, I probably use more water than I initially thought. I asked a friend to time me once, and it turns out that my showers are a little under 8 minutes rather than the 5 that I had expected. So, I apologize to all those people that I bragged to about taking 5 minute showers. I still protest that showers can be short, regardless of how long your hair is!!! Also, I noted the amount of time that I spent washing dishes, and I kept my loads of laundry to a minimum. With the electricity challenge, I simply kept on one incandescent light in my room when I needed to do homework, and that was enough. Most of the rest of the time I could get by with just opening the blinds in my room. Natural light is a beautiful thing! My roommate challenged me often, however, keeping on more lights than we really need. I also made sure to turn off lights when no one was in the room and limit my leisure time on the computer. I don’t know how the technology fast people could survive without a computer for 4 days. My computer is a very important element in my school work. Wrapping things up. This lifestyle project helped me to think about what I throw away, reduce waste in the workplace, and continue to conserve water and electricity. It’s been fun! Peace out!
Monday, November 23, 2009
What it all boils down to
Well, this week was an experience- four days! I feel like I'd be repeating myself too much if I summarized how each day/project went like I have the last two weeks, so I'm just going to list off the obstacles of this week.
TECHNOLOGY FAST: papers, tests and homework were plentiful, the internet would've been welcomed with open arms; plans for going home this week would have been much more extensive had I had my cell phone; I could have gotten more online Christmas shopping done with the internet as well; the rain limited my outdoor time, so much time was spent..thinking..? (pro or con?)
ELECTRICITY: the rain limited the sunlight that I had been using to light my room-lights were on much more often; one lightbulb in my bathroom is flickering, so instead of turning on that one light in the middle of the bathroom, my suitemates tend to turn on two other lights to compensate; with all the extra studying, I was for an unfortunate amount of time=lights on much more often in the early mornings
WASTE: I recieved a couple packages in the mail, one contained packing peanuts, one was in a large box, and the other was in a thick padded (not recyclable) envelope; with all the running around of this week, my roommate ate a lot of fast food, quickly filling our trashcan.
By these cons, it must look like I had a difficult week, but honestly, it was comparable to the other two. I take this as a great sign because doubling the amount of days I do the projects should double the effort. I really loved this project. As cliche as this totally is, it made me just stop and think and not worry and slow down. All of those are actions not usually taken by me, all very unusual feelings for me. A couple of times when on a normal day I'd be drowning in anxiety, I felt like I was breathing the lightest, freshest air I had ever encountered. I completely plan on continuing to every once in a while do a technology fast. And as the waste and electricity reduction were not that difficult, I 100% plan to contine with those. Through the weeks, I pretty much did those every day, it was hard to not feel guilty when I threw something away.. haha
Week 3
I am glad the Lifestyle Project is over. This doesn’t mean I will go back to my old habits or that I didn’t learn anything, but being able to honestly follow through some of the categories has definitely been a challenge (which was the whole purpose of the project anyways). For instance, trying to go for four consecutive days without producing any garbage was not possible for me although I definitely tried. I can recall having thrown away a paper towel, a cupcake liner, and a Quakers Rice Snacks bag mainly because my hunger made me forget about the trash the food would create before I ate it. I realized I have also been throwing away the wipes in the weight room to sanitize the machines. I felt it was something I couldn’t avoid since many people have been sick lately. I also ate some ground meat that was in some pasta in the Commons last week and didn’t realize it until I was almost done with the portion. But besides these mishaps I greatly reduced the amount of trash I created and realized how much food packaging could not end up in landfills by eating food that can be composted. This project has also helped me avoid the vending machines, which has not only saved me money but also encouraged me to eat much healthier. Not eating meat, using less water and using less energy have been easier tasks that have actually been easier to do this past week. In an effort to continue these new habits in the future, I am also planning to buy a dish towel instead of using napkins all the time to wash dishes, eat more fruits and vegetables that can be composted and buy a plastic container instead of using the compostable to-go containers in the Commons.
project: over. changes: ongoing.
Last week! (but the composting will continue....)
Week 3!
Anyone want some clothes?
I also did some more work in tracking where my clothes come from and while most of my clothes are second hand, almost all the others were probably produced in an inhumane manner. I also discovered how far say a pair of pants travels before it reaches the store and carbon footprint of a pair of sock is more than a bit excessive even if you only figure in travel. Basically what I've come too is I have way more clothes than I need, especially shirts, so if anyone would like some clothes just let me know. I'll wash and deliver them. I think if I can't manage to give enough away via friends and family I'll probably just give the rest to the caring place. I know the next time someone in the McCombs Concourse asks if I want to buy a shirt to support their cause, I'll probably just give them some money and ask them to keep the shirt, because I certainly don't need anymore clothes.
Week 3
wrapping up
Thanks to everyone who came out and to everyone who donated supplies and clothes - I hope you all enjoyed yourselves!